WEBVTT

00:00:05.000 --> 00:00:12.810
Why are pro housing groups split on Proposition forty five? This

00:00:12.810 --> 00:00:18.290
article is being read by an automated voice generated by Everlit. For

00:00:18.290 --> 00:00:22.930
nearly a decade, California's yes, in my backyard activists and other pro

00:00:22.930 --> 00:00:28.050
development advocates have wanted to overhaul California's signature environmental law, to clear

00:00:28.050 --> 00:00:30.370
the way for more housing construction.

00:00:30.680 --> 00:00:34.120
Now Proposition forty five is on the ballot. Supporters say it would,

00:00:34.200 --> 00:00:38.360
among other things, overhaul that law, known as the California Environmental Quality

00:00:38.360 --> 00:00:42.040
Act, or CEQA, to clear the way for, you guessed it, more

00:00:42.040 --> 00:00:47.810
housing construction. So why Area Yimbis divided? Assemblymember Buffy Wicks, an Oakland

00:00:47.810 --> 00:00:51.650
Democrat and one of the movement's most stalwart champions In the legislature,

00:00:51.810 --> 00:00:55.250
is for it. So is the bulk of the building industry, including

00:00:55.250 --> 00:01:00.920
many major for and nonprofit developers. Bay Area Pro Housing advocates East

00:01:00.920 --> 00:01:04.760
Bay for Everyone and the Greenbelt Alliance, two typical allies of Wix,

00:01:04.840 --> 00:01:09.310
are emphatically against it. In the uncommitted middle lies the lion's share

00:01:09.310 --> 00:01:14.590
of California Yimbiism. Abundant Housing Los Angeles Spur, and both California Yimbi

00:01:14.590 --> 00:01:19.390
and Yimbi Action, the movement's two flagship advocacy organizations, have all taken

00:01:19.390 --> 00:01:24.770
neutral positions. It's been a weird campaign so far, said Ali Sapirman,

00:01:24.930 --> 00:01:26.130
advocacy manager at The

00:01:26.130 --> 00:01:30.690
Housing Action Coalition, an urban building industry group that supports the measure.

00:01:30.930 --> 00:01:35.290
The housing community has been a little bit fractured. Those fissures aren't

00:01:35.290 --> 00:01:39.690
over whether more homes should be built across California. Instead, it mostly

00:01:39.690 --> 00:01:43.870
boils down to a question of where. The central question here is

00:01:43.870 --> 00:01:48.110
how you feel about sprawl Max Dubler of California Yimby, wrote in

00:01:48.110 --> 00:01:52.350
the group's non endorsement statement, referring to low density housing development at

00:01:52.350 --> 00:01:57.300
the edge of metro areas. Though some exurban growth will necessarily be

00:01:57.300 --> 00:02:01.060
part of solving our housing shortage, he expressed concern about making it

00:02:01.060 --> 00:02:05.620
easier to build car dependent sprawl housing and the freeways and water

00:02:05.620 --> 00:02:10.900
infrastructure necessary to serve that sprawl. To sprawl or not to sprawl.

00:02:11.860 --> 00:02:15.380
For nearly a decade the legislature has been on a tier, passing

00:02:15.380 --> 00:02:19.780
streamlining bills aimed at seeing up the regulatory approval of new construction.

00:02:19.940 --> 00:02:23.460
Almost all of those laws have only applied to projects in places

00:02:23.460 --> 00:02:29.580
where homes and other infrastructure already exist. Prioritizing so called infill development

00:02:29.580 --> 00:02:34.140
helped wrangle together a coalition of developers and construction labor unions, but

00:02:34.140 --> 00:02:38.780
also a diverse swath of democratic leaning advocates whose interest in seeing

00:02:38.780 --> 00:02:43.750
more apartments and condos goes beyond the cause of affordability alone. That

00:02:43.750 --> 00:02:47.990
includes climate activists who want to see less commuter car traffic, transit,

00:02:48.150 --> 00:02:52.630
bicycle, and pedestrian advocates who want more riders and walkers, and urbanists

00:02:52.630 --> 00:02:57.450
who want Los Angeles to more closely resemble Barcelona. In breaking from

00:02:57.450 --> 00:03:01.130
that urban focus, Prop forty five is driving a wedge inside that

00:03:01.130 --> 00:03:05.800
coalition. If passed, the measure would speed up the review process required

00:03:05.800 --> 00:03:10.440
under SIQA pronounced SICFA for all types of housing projects. That includes

00:03:10.440 --> 00:03:15.240
transit adjacent downtown condo towers, but also freshly paved subdivisions at the

00:03:15.240 --> 00:03:20.290
metropolitan fringe. The measure is a doubling down on essentially seventy five

00:03:20.290 --> 00:03:23.890
years of land use patterns that we know haven't worked, said Jordan

00:03:23.890 --> 00:03:28.530
Grimes, legislative director with Greenbelt Alliance, which opposes the measure. It's a

00:03:28.530 --> 00:03:34.000
return to the sprawl era. Not everyone in the movement necessarily sees

00:03:34.000 --> 00:03:37.440
that as a bad thing. Among those who want California to build

00:03:37.440 --> 00:03:41.520
its way out of its current housing shortage, opinions differ over whether

00:03:41.520 --> 00:03:46.340
more environmentally friendly infill development alone is up to the task. I'm

00:03:46.340 --> 00:03:49.060
an all of the above person when it comes to housing, said

00:03:49.060 --> 00:03:52.740
Wicks, explaining her support of the measure. I think we need housing

00:03:52.740 --> 00:03:57.470
of all different types, shapes, and sizes. An earlier version of this

00:03:57.470 --> 00:04:01.390
rift first emerged earlier this decade, when a handful of Bay Area

00:04:01.390 --> 00:04:04.910
Tech investors announced plans to build a brand new city on Solano

00:04:04.910 --> 00:04:09.150
County farmland in twenty twenty three, under the banner of California Forever.

00:04:09.310 --> 00:04:13.230
Some Yimbee commentators applauded the plan as a welcome injection of much

00:04:13.230 --> 00:04:18.620
needed supply. Others decried it as sprawl dressed in urbanist clothing. With

00:04:18.620 --> 00:04:21.820
Prop forty five, that regional debate is now playing out at a

00:04:21.820 --> 00:04:27.890
statewide scale. Housing front and center. Prop forty five is about

00:04:27.890 --> 00:04:32.950
much more than housing policy. CEQA requires public agencies to review the

00:04:32.950 --> 00:04:37.830
possible environmental consequences of the decisions the make, including the permitting of

00:04:37.830 --> 00:04:43.270
private projects. For decades, industry groups, developers, and more recently, housing supply

00:04:43.270 --> 00:04:46.630
boosters have said the law makes it too easy for project opponents

00:04:46.630 --> 00:04:52.430
to jam up worthwhile projects by repeatedly demanding additional analysis. The clock

00:04:52.430 --> 00:04:55.790
is endless, and the number of people and entities who can challenge

00:04:55.790 --> 00:05:00.270
you are also endless, said Linda Mandalini of Eden Housing, an affordable

00:05:00.270 --> 00:05:05.480
housing developer. Prop forty five would not exempt any projects from environmental

00:05:05.480 --> 00:05:09.800
review outright, but for projects deemed essential, it would narrow the focus

00:05:09.800 --> 00:05:13.240
of these reviews and require the to wrap up within three hundred

00:05:13.240 --> 00:05:17.640
and sixty five business days. Any resulting litigation would also face a

00:05:17.640 --> 00:05:21.560
shot clock. Judges would have two hundred and seventy business days to

00:05:21.560 --> 00:05:25.320
resolve them. Such lawsuits would also be made harder to sustain in

00:05:25.320 --> 00:05:31.160
court. Aside from housing, essential projects include roads, hospitals, schools, clean energy

00:05:31.160 --> 00:05:36.460
projects, water, and broadband infrastructure. But housing has loomed large in the

00:05:36.460 --> 00:05:40.540
electoral debate. The Yes on Forty Five campaign has touted the support

00:05:40.540 --> 00:05:45.660
of affordable housing developers and housing advocates, while pointing to housing affordability

00:05:45.660 --> 00:05:50.560
concerns as the initial impetus for the measure. It's easy to see

00:05:50.560 --> 00:05:56.000
why. Environmental challenges to often innocuous seeming housing projects have regularly generated

00:05:56.000 --> 00:05:59.760
headlines for years, helping to cement the idea among lawmakers and many

00:05:59.760 --> 00:06:03.840
voters that sequa is a major cause of the state's housing woes.

00:06:04.250 --> 00:06:08.330
Environmental justice groups and their allies have spent years fighting against that

00:06:08.330 --> 00:06:12.970
argument in the legislature. Though Prop forty five does not exempt essential

00:06:12.970 --> 00:06:17.610
projects from environmental review outright, it just shortens and hems in the

00:06:17.610 --> 00:06:20.890
process, these groups have now lined up to oppose it for much

00:06:20.890 --> 00:06:22.810
the same reason. They reject them.

00:06:22.810 --> 00:06:27.900
Premise that Sequa needs fixing. But for opponents like Grimes, who supported

00:06:27.900 --> 00:06:31.660
many recent streamlining bills, the argument that the law is holding up

00:06:31.660 --> 00:06:35.900
desperately needed residential construction is a year out of date. Last

00:06:35.900 --> 00:06:39.740
year’s the Governor signed Assembly Bill one hundred and thirty, a Wix

00:06:39.740 --> 00:06:45.070
authored measure that exempted most infill housing from the Sequa. Since becoming

00:06:45.070 --> 00:06:48.910
law in july twenty twenty five, developers have used it to entitle

00:06:49.070 --> 00:06:54.270
17,913 units of housing, according to the Office of Land Use And

00:06:54.270 --> 00:06:58.740
Climate Innovation, a state agency. When you look at what's left to

00:06:58.740 --> 00:07:03.140
do on urban housing, there are absolutely still barriers, said Grimes, whose

00:07:03.140 --> 00:07:08.340
organization applauded last year's exemption. Sequea just isn't one of the The

00:07:08.340 --> 00:07:11.620
task of the No on Forty five campaign, he said is to

00:07:11.620 --> 00:07:16.720
convince enough voters that we've actually solved this problem. Are we done

00:07:16.720 --> 00:07:21.650
here? Many developers and affordable housing advocates, even those working in urban

00:07:21.650 --> 00:07:26.590
areas, dispute that Sequa is no longer a major obstacle. Last year's

00:07:26.590 --> 00:07:31.310
exemption does not exempt projects larger than twenty acres, which means supersized

00:07:31.310 --> 00:07:36.550
urban redevelopment projects are still subject to the old process. Prop forty

00:07:36.550 --> 00:07:40.070
five also applies shot clocks to other permits issued later in the

00:07:40.070 --> 00:07:45.190
development process, and which regularly slow a project more than environmental review.

00:07:45.680 --> 00:07:49.360
And while state laws like last year's infill carve out may grant

00:07:49.360 --> 00:07:52.880
certain developers the right to ignore Sequa, there is nothing to stop

00:07:52.880 --> 00:07:57.200
a deep pocketed opponent from suing anyway. Putting time limits on those

00:07:57.200 --> 00:08:01.120
lawsuits could be the difference between a project succeeding and being delayed

00:08:01.120 --> 00:08:05.890
to death, said Mandalini. She points to the planned one hundred thirty

00:08:05.890 --> 00:08:10.130
unit affordable housing project, that Eden Housing has been trying to and

00:08:10.130 --> 00:08:13.810
failing to build in the Bay Area suburb of Livermore since twenty

00:08:13.810 --> 00:08:18.260
eighteen as an example. In twenty twenty one, a non profit funded

00:08:18.260 --> 00:08:22.340
by a handful of well heeled Livermore residents sued the city, arguing

00:08:22.340 --> 00:08:26.660
that it hadn't done enough environmental analysis on a housing development that

00:08:26.660 --> 00:08:29.540
would be built on a former grocery store parking lot behind a

00:08:29.540 --> 00:08:33.780
row of downtown restaurants. A lower court ruled that the group's sequa

00:08:33.780 --> 00:08:39.030
arguments were almost utterly without merit. An appellate court agreed. The state

00:08:39.030 --> 00:08:43.270
Supreme Court allowed that ruling to stand. But by then two years

00:08:43.270 --> 00:08:47.620
had passed. Every year you lose in litigation is real money for

00:08:47.620 --> 00:08:51.060
real projects and another year that one hundred and thirty families don't

00:08:51.060 --> 00:08:54.420
get to live in that housing, said Mandalini. It's a great way

00:08:54.420 --> 00:08:59.310
to kill a project. Even an infill project. But among some pro

00:08:59.310 --> 00:09:03.790
housing supporters of the proposition, the infill versus sprawl debate isn't much

00:09:03.790 --> 00:09:08.600
of a debate at all. We're not an urbanist organization, said Mahdi

00:09:08.600 --> 00:09:11.960
Manji with the Inner City Law Center, a legal aid provider and

00:09:11.960 --> 00:09:16.600
housing advocacy group in Los Angeles Skid Row. The group supports Prop

00:09:16.680 --> 00:09:19.560
45 and doesn't mind the concept of more housing far from the

00:09:19.560 --> 00:09:23.000
city's core. To the extent it results in housing that is a

00:09:23.000 --> 00:09:26.600
little more affordable in Lancaster and Palmdale, a lot of our clients

00:09:26.600 --> 00:09:31.250
live out in Lancaster and Palmdale. This story was originally published by

00:09:31.250 --> 00:09:35.970
CalMatters and distributed through a partnership with the Associated Press.

